怎样定义淫秽或是淫乱,在不同的思想下,分别处于何种状态

谢邀,不能定义。“I know it when I see it”是美国前大法官波特·斯图尔特的一句名言,他在处理一桩淫秽电影案件的时候,曾用这句话表示淫秽电影对社会所造成的影响是很难定义的。此话后成为美国最高法院使用率最高的话语之一。他的原话如下:I shall not today attempt further to define the kinds of material I understand to be embraced within that shorthand description , and perhaps I could never succeed in intelligibly doing so. But I know it when I see it, and the motion picture involved in this case is not that.大意为,明确阐述何为淫秽(严格定义)是难以做到的,但是我只要看到它,就知道它是不是(淫秽的)。这里体现的是法官的自由心证权。


    推荐阅读